Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe – Stillwater

Welcome to Pickleman’s in Stillwater, proudly serving Oklahoma State fans and the surrounding community with fresh, toasted sandwiches, signature pizzas, soups, and salads — all just steps from the action on Washington Avenue.

Whether you’re fueling up before a game or recovering after Homecoming (we know how it goes), we’re your spot for good vibes and even better food.

How to Find Us

We’re located on Washington Avenue, between Fuzzy’s and Wooden Nickel — right in the heart of Cowboy country. If you’re in town for a game, a concert, or just a downtown stroll, you’re close to Pickleman’s.

What Makes Us Unique

We opened our doors during OSU’s Homecoming Week in October 2019 — and let’s just say, we hit the ground running. Stillwater’s Homecoming is the biggest in the nation, and it shows. The energy, the crowd, the spirit? It’s insane — in the best way.

But here’s a little-known fact: Garth Brooks once played right here — back when this location was a bar! So yeah, you’re literally dining in a piece of country music history.

What You Might Not Know

Stillwater isn’t just a college town — it’s a community packed with personality. From football traditions to music legends, there’s always something happening here. Come for the food, stay for the stories.

Our Customers

Our guests are respectful, loyal, and full of Cowboy pride. Whether it’s their first visit or their hundredth, they make Pickleman’s feel like home.

Staff Picks

Stillwater’s team favorite? The Buffalo Pizza — a bold, spicy tribute to OSU’s orange-and-black spirit. And if you’re craving a sandwich? You can’t go wrong with the #17 (add pepperoni) — it’s a top-tier move.

Whether you’re celebrating a Cowboys win, reliving a Garth Brooks memory, or just in need of your toasted sandwich fix, we’re here to serve it up fresh and fast — right here in the heart of Stillwater.